A Post that Says Generals and politicians have Failed the Army: Kashmir Imbroglio

This is reproduced froma post on a Ex Servicemans site. I acknowledge the contribution of the anonymous retired Lieutenant Colonel

Free India legion As per reports, soldiers on the sentry duty on the army camp, did not fire upon the approaching terrorist vehicle because of caution imposed on them after the Anantnag incident. Sentry challenging procedures are now things of the past. We are now engulfed by WOM (War by Other Means). Sentries are knocked out first. There is a need to refine these outmoded methods. A "LAXMAN REKHA" needs to be drawn around all fixed localities with a public warning, that anyone crossing it would be shot. A CCTV monitoring system with audio warning system have to be installed in sensitive localities. Time to upgrade our security apparatus keeping in view of the changing form of war, highlighted by the WOM. Why does not this nation and its leaders understand the nuances of this "Designer war" heaped upon India by Pakistan since 1989? Unfortunately, even most military minds, both serving and retired, have failed to understand the reality of this war. It has nothing to do with 'Law and Order' ; it is war, Sir! Most important , it is for Generals to understand and grasp its characteristics and stop reacting to civilian hue and cry --- they will keep shouting and whining for whatever you do. "Was it a mistake"? This question goes to the Army Cdr and the Corps cdr who jumped to conclusions when some young men got killed, on a case of mistaken identity, perpetuated by the unwillingness of the youngsters to stop when challenged. Now, what do they have to say? They had betrayed their own soldiers, who became cautious in a War Zone, and the result is for everyone to see. GENERALS SHOULD STOP PLAYING TO THE GALLERY, AND ALLOW SOLDIERS TO DO THEIR JOB. In fighting WOM launched by enemy, genuine mistakes will take place, because terrorists do not roam with headbands. We ought to accept such mistakes when we deploy the army for restoration of the situation. Everyone must understand the real purpose of AFSPA. It is meant to cover unintentional mistakes made by soldiers in the course of the performance of their duty. Any order which prevents soldiers full liberty and freedom, is counter productive and it ought to be countermanded. When Anantnag incident took place last month, Corps Commander of 15 corps and Army Commander of Northern Command, had both called it a mistake, obviously giving a wrong message to commanders down the line. And the result is what happened at URI, the other day. Stop sermonizing soldiers ---- instead, give them full support for their actions.

A Voice of Anguish: Will Anything Happen?

Here is a post recieved from a CISF officer. it is worth reading it.

 

Dear Brig. Kamboj Sir, Please print this piece of writing in the IESM blog. This is not at all any political opinion but I am purely addressing the long suffering predicaments, continuous loss of life and limbs of the Indian Army and CRPF personnel, something cannot be allowed to go on any longer. When in the last four days fifteen CRPF personnel and ten Indian Army personnel lost their life in fighting terrorists, we saw the most disgraceful behaviour of the opposition led a disgraceful direction-less man who and his party still want to see him as a future PM. The opposition spent three days shouting, screaming and disrupting the parliamentary work on a TRIVIAL COMMENT by a female parliamentarian which any other country's politicians would not have given two hoots about it. 

 HOW COME SUCH POLITICIANS BEHAVE SO BADLY AND DO NO REAL WORK IN THE PARLIAMENT AND GET AWAY WITH IT WITHOUT PAYING ANY PRICE YEAR ON YEAR? The failures of the spineless politicians of all parties to deal with terrorism both by pakis and internally is beyond any limit and unparalleled seen anywhere in the world. I will just give a few examples-

 

* In October 1947 a complete winnable war within another few hours, pro-Pakistani Nehru gave away 40% of Kashmir to Pakistan and he made such a blunder of going for plebiscite which no other winning Army has ever done anywhere in the world. 

 ** The Naxalite/Maoist movements started in 1967 and it is still there after 48 years. No politician including Modi is prepare a take a decisive decision to CRUSH IT ONCE FOR ALL leaving CRPF personnel slaughtered every now and then since 1967. 

 *** The blunder of pro-Pakistani and anti-Armed forces Nehru in 1962 India-China War caused enormous loss of life and injuries but no lesson was learnt.

 **** In 1965 War, all the strategically advantageous places were given away by Sastri, once again India showed it's failure to deal firmly with rogue Pakis. 

 ***** In 1971 war after taking 93,000 prisoners when Pakis were on their knees and where India could make Pakis agree to completely give up the demand of Kashmir then released the 93,000 prisoners without any condition. Once again one of the biggest blunders of Indira Gandhi. The Great Sam Manekshaw was shocked with the decision and said to Indira Gandhi "They (Pakis) made you a fool of yourself".

 ****** In 1999 Kargil War, Indian Army lost 579 life and nearly 2000 serous injuries simply because of weak Vajpayee would not allow Indian Air Force to cross the LoC and bomb occupied positions of Pakis. So was his utter failure to deal with Pakis after the parliament attack in 2002. HE WAS STILL INVITING MUSHARAFF FOR BIRIYANI IN AGRA. He should have been thrown into the dustbin after the war for his giving two hoots with the life of Indian soldiers while he himself was in three-tyre security cover. 

 ******* 2008 Mumbai terror attack was totally conducted by Paki ISI and Army but still no action was taken and India continued appeasement policies with bizarre propaganda of AAMAN KI AASHA.

 ******** Since 1982 Khalistani (Sponsored by Pakis) movement and more so over the last 32 years Pakis are totally carrying out a proxy-war where victims are mostly Indian Army, BSF, CRPF personnel and civilians those living in border areas and bomb-blasts victims. I can go on with the list as long as my arm.

The entire nation had so much expectation of Modi but it appears he is no different from any of the previous weak PMs when it comes to dealing with Pakis and terrorism. 

Since becoming PM, Modi has become A GANDHIAN, HAVING A GANDHI'S STATUE IN HIS OFFICE AND PROMOTING GANDHI ANYWHERE AND EVERYWHERE. Gandhi was a creation of most devious and evil British to keep the Indians subjugated in a manipulated way. Modi made a promise earlier to Great Netaji Subhas Bose's family, that, he would reveal Mukharjee Commission Report and now even from that, he has backed off. Why? Is it to safeguard Gandhi, Patel and Nehru and their roles against Great Netaji 

Subhas Bose, the greatest freedom fighter India ever had. With such low life politicians in the parliament, is it any wonder why Paki kicks our knees everyday, will continue to do so and why OROP is still a SEE-SAW? Jai Hind and Vande Mataram. Amit Bhadhuri Ex-CISF and IESM Member

Remembering Ken Nortan: Was he the Greater Boxer than Muhammed Ali ?

Legends are made and then they live forever. The recent death of Ken Norton at the age of 70 is the death of one such legend. Norton was suffering for 2 years from a variety of ailments and finally the boxer passed away on 19 September 2013. Norton was different from Ali. Whereas Ali dodged the draft by making incendiary statements like “The Vietcong don’t call me Nigger”. In contrast Norton served in the army from 1963-72. Ali converted to Islam; he was Cassius Clay earlier, while Norton struck to the roots of what he had been brought up as, a Christian.

The fights between Norton and Ali are the stuff legends are made off. In the first bout in 1973, Norton battered Ali and broke his Jaw. This is no mean feat against a boxer of the caliber of Ali, who had won the world heavyweight boxing title 3 times. Ali was confused with the tactics of Norton and lost the fight on points. In two other fights Ali won, but on points though many felt the real winner was Norton. Why, this happened? The fact is that the powers that be in the boxing world had decided that Ali must be champion and thus Norton had to lose. All the same Norton and Foreman are bracketed with Ali. We must bear in mind that if Norton and Foreman were not there would Muhammad Ali be as great? Norton won 33 out his 42 bouts and that is feat by itself. He was ailing during the last 2 years and finally father time took its toll and Norton is no more. But he has done enough to be remembered as a great fighter, a man who broke the Jaw of Ali and almost beat him in subsequent encounters. He packed a vicious punch

Navjot Singh Sidhu, Salman Khan and now Jayalalitha: Indian Judiciary has not changed .

In 2007 Navjot Singh Sidhu the BJP leader from Punjab was convicted by the Punjab and Haryana High Court of Man Slaughter and sentenced to 2 years in prison. Sidhu appealed to the Supreme Court , which stayed the punishment. Now 7 years have elapsed and the Supreme Court has not found time to hear the case of Sidhu. In the meantime the Sikh is enjoying himself and minting money with television shows. Alas what ails Indian judiciary and in particular the Supreme Court that the case of Sidhu is not decided in 7 years? Take the case of Salman Khan convicted for a jail term of 5 years under the wild life act and ths man is also roaming free. The latest is the corruption case against Jayalalitha the ex-Chief Minister of Tamilnadu, who like others has been able to get a reprieve from the Supreme Court and instead of undergoing a jail term is relaxing at home in airconditioned comfort. One thing is crysat clear. In India the Judiciary including the Supreme Court have a different set of laws for the rich and poor. I wonder how many stay on punishment the Supreme Court has given to poor litigants who have no money. The Judiciary more than any other aspect of Indian life needs a thorough overhaul and if that means sending 50% of the judges home so be it.

Is Raj Thackeray Correct: All Crimes of Rape and Murder are done by Biharis?

Raj Thacheray is a politician who is prone to making sensational and provocative statements. For this many FIR’s have been filed against him. Not for a moment will I support Raj Thackeray, but having said that it is important we analyse the crimes of rape and women in India. Socio Economic Situation in Bihar There is no doubt that the socio economic situation in Bihar is bad. The caste divide is extreme, so much so that people will be surprised to know that in Patna even the Police billets are segregated on caste lines. The second point that must be emphasised is that Bihar is a feudal state where the women have been subjugated and made second class citizens. Add to this the caste equation and you have a deadly concoction of the worst case of socio economic scenario . Bihar is almost a lawless state, despite all efforts of Nitesh Kumar the state remains steeped in obscurantism and backwardness. Industrial production is nonexistent and jobs are difficult to come by. With the loss of the mineral rich areas to Jharkhand, Bihar has almost empty coffers. Poor Economy and Migration Thus the pressure to migrate to other states is extreme and many Biharis migrate to Delhi, Calcutta and Bombay for a livelihood. When this crowd leaves Bihar they mostly leave their families behind and work single in the metropolis. Conditioned by a feudal background these Bihar men are easily susceptible to crime. There is no doubt that a large number of crimes of rape and other sex related matters can be traced to people from Bihar. Unable to visualize a freedom of girls in dress and demeanour, that they have not seen in Bihar these Bihari workers are easily swayed and base thoughts come to them resulting in crimes of rape. Unfortunately this also applies to Eastern Utter Pradesh which is also the sister state of Bihar in terms of obscurantism and backwardness. Last Word Perhaps the only solution is to not only enact stringent laws, but also improve the socio- economic scenario in Bihar and UP. Incidentally it is not only Raj who has articulated these thoughts but the Delhi Chief Minister Sheila Dixit has also earlier gone on record with the same observations. The fact is the Bihar and UP constitutes 40% of India’s population and curbing this menace of rape and crime by men of this state is no easy task

Can Modi be Countered ?

A rag tag opposoition is planning to oppose Narendra Modi. Most of the opponents are those who have been roundly defeated by the elctorate and had ambitions to be Prime minister. Among them are men like Nitesh kumar. This man thought he would be king( become Prime Minister). Unfortunately he over estimated himself and was soundly thrashed at the elections. In panic he joined up witha convicted criminal lalu Prasad Yadav( convicted in the Fodder scam) and is hoping he can survive the Modi avalanche. Most other leaders like Rahul Gandhi, Ms Mayawati, Mamta Bannerjee, Karunanidhi among other wont be able to make a come back for at least a decade , by which time we would be writing their obituary RIP

Ms jayalalitha has had her dreams Shattered

The special court in Bangalore sentenced Jayalalitha for a prison term of 4 years and also fined her Rs 100 crores and on failure to pay a further prison term of one year. What does this mean? It means that apart from the jail term, she is debarred to contest an election for 6 years and is immediately disqualified as a MLA as per the Peoples Representation Act. Theere is merit in the judgement of the court and the net effect is that this schemer has been effectively debarred for aspiring to be the Prime Minister of India. This was the ambition of the lady, to sit in the PM's chair. I wonder how a lady as corrupt as Jayalalitha could aspire to be the Prime Minister of India ? This is the bane of a democracy like India where the voters vote more on caste and secterian lines than on merit. God save India !